The Oddfellows Arms, Sherburn in Elmet ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

40 Low Street, Sherburn in Elmet, United Kingdom, LS25 6BA

View all

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A list of all available modes of transport

City Centre

Sherburn in Elmet300 m

Airports

Leeds Bradford (LBA) 36.0 km

Doncaster Sheffield (DSA) 53.4 km

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Internet

Parking

Car park

Luggage storage

24-hour services

General

Smoking allowed in designated areas
Parking

Services

Tours/Ticket assistance

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area

Children

Game room

Spa & Leisure

Garden area

Media

Television

Location

40 Low Street, Sherburn in Elmet, United Kingdom, LS25 6BA

Map view

40 Low Street, Sherburn in Elmet, United Kingdom, LS25 6BA

City landmarks

Sherburn in Elmet Methodist Church

650 m

St Joseph The Worker

690 m

Church

All Saints Church

1.1 km

Keepers Cottage Lotherton Lane Aberford

Lotherton

5.1 km

South Milford Methodist Church

1.9 km

Church

St. Mary's

2.2 km

Leeds LS25 5PD

Steeton Hall Gateway

2.3 km

Holy Trinity

2.6 km

Church

Holy Trinity Church

2.6 km

Sherburn in Elmet Castle Hill

3.7 km

The Cross Barwick in Elmet

The Barwick Maypole

3.6 km

Scarthingwell Golf Club

3.9 km

Church of St Mary the Virgin

3.8 km

All Saints

3.8 km

Church

Church of St Wilfrid

4.0 km

Church Fenton Methodist Church

4.1 km

Selby Fork

4.1 km

Lead

St Mary's Chapel

4.5 km

Towton

4.8 km

Cemetery

Towton Battlefield

5.4 km

Nearby

St Joseph The Worker

140 m

Sherburn in Elmet Methodist Church

180 m

Restaurants

Shun Hing

570 m

Low Street

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

72%

liked the hotel and would stay again

7.2/10

Very good

Rooms

6.4

Location

7.5

Service

8.6

Dining

8.0

Jordan

United Kingdom, December 2024

5.4/10

I had a pleasant stay at The Oddfellows Arms in Sherburn in Elmet. The staff, particularly Maggie, were super friendly and accommodating, even helping us out of a last-minute scramble. While my room was clean and comfortable, it did show signs of needing some maintenance like missing hooks and mirrors. Overall, it was a good experience for the price I paid.

Rooms

8.0

The room was basic but served its purpose well. It had a comfortable double bed and an ensuite bathroom stocked with essentials. However, it lacked some maintenance touches that would have made it feel more complete.

Service

10.0

Service was really good. Maggie and her team went above and beyond to ensure we had a great stay, particularly when they arranged a room for us after a booking mix-up.

Location

8.0

The location was convenient, allowing us to easily explore nearby attractions in York while enjoying the quieter village atmosphere of Sherburn in Elmet.

Dining

Facilities

7.0

Facilities included essential amenities like tea/coffee and clean linens. Despite the basic setup, I found it adequate for my needs for a night.

Sebastian

United Kingdom, November 2024

6.6/10

I had a mixed experience at The Oddfellows Arms. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, especially Maggie, who saved the day with quick room arrangements and a lift from Leeds Fest. However, the room itself fell short with cleanliness issues and uncomfortable amenities, making for a less than ideal stay.

Rooms

5.0

The room was not what I expected. it had issues with cleanliness and comfort. I felt the need for a better-maintained environment.

Service

10.0

Maggie's assistance was really good, going above and beyond during our stay. her attentiveness made a challenging situation manageable.

Location

8.0

The location is great for accessibility, especially being close to events like Leeds Fest. it made traveling easy.

Dining

6.0

While there were limited food options, the atmosphere was cozy, and the local food scene nearby is something to check out. I appreciated the community feel.

Facilities

5.0

Basic amenities were provided, but I felt the room lacked proper upkeep, with some facilities needing attention. it didn’t fully meet my expectations.

Emily

United Kingdom, November 2024

5.2/10

I found my stay at The Oddfellows Arms to be a mixed bag. The warm welcome and clean room were definite highlights, but the overall state of the accommodation left much to be desired. Though the pub atmosphere was lively and inviting, the condition of my room was quite disappointing.

Rooms

5.0

My double room was basic but needed TLC. The ensuite shower had some issues and the overall decor felt tired. However, it was warm and clean with complimentary tea and coffee.

Service

7.0

The staff were friendly and welcoming, making me feel at home right away. Their attentiveness added to the experience, even if the facilities required improvement.

Location

6.0

Located in a village setting, the pub had a cozy charm. Its proximity to York is great for sightseeing, though the immediate surroundings could use more options.

Dining

8.0

I didn't eat at the pub this time, but the menu looked appealing and I heard great things about their Sunday lunch and other meals from friends.

Facilities

5.0

Basic amenities were provided, which included tea and coffee facilities. Parking was convenient, but more improvements are needed across the board.

Jacob

United Kingdom, November 2024

6.2/10

The Oddfellows Arms has a cozy vibe with a warm atmosphere and friendly staff, but the room needs a bit of work. I enjoyed the lovely local pub feel and fantastic food, yet some aspects felt a tad basic. Overall, it's got a nice charm, but there's definitely room for improvement.

Rooms

5.0

My room was basic but totally adequate for one night, featuring a double bed and ensuite shower. However, I noticed it wasn't made up for the day, which was a bit off-putting.

Service

9.0

The bar staff and landlady were super friendly and provided fantastic service. I really appreciated their attentiveness during my stay.

Location

Dining

10.0

I had a hot beef ciabatta that was honestly amazing, along with homemade coleslaw and chips. The food really hit the spot!

Facilities

5.0

While the basics like tea/coffee facilities were there, the room and bathroom could use a proper upgrade to enhance the stay experience.

Sophia

United Kingdom, October 2024

5.8/10

My stay at The Oddfellows Arms was pleasant. I found the room clean and cozy with a very welcoming atmosphere. However, one encounter with a staff member left me feeling a bit uneasy. I appreciated the charming character of the space, but the experience could have been more consistently positive.

Rooms

9.0

The room was warm and impeccably clean, featuring a comfy double bed and a tidy ensuite shower room. I found plenty of complimentary tea and coffee, which was a nice touch.

Service

7.0

While most of the staff were friendly, I had an awkward interaction with one woman who seemed quite abrupt. On the other hand, the landlord was incredibly helpful when I needed a taxi, which balanced my overall impression of service.

Location

8.0

Situated between York and Leeds, the location is great for exploring nearby attractions, making it a convenient base for sightseeing.

Dining

8.0

I didn't have dinner, but I did enjoy breakfast, which included cereals and freshly made toast. It was just what I needed to start my day.

Facilities

7.0

I felt the basic amenities were adequately provided, making my overnight stay comfortable enough for relaxation.